Tag: Mikhail Rasumny

Wake Island (1942)

Wake Island (1942)

Wartime propaganda, very well made and still stirring that helped inspire a nation to fight

Director: John Farrow

Cast: Brian Donlevy (Major Caton), Macdonald Carey (Lt Bruce Cameron), Robert Preston (Pvt Joe Doyle), William Bendix (Pvt Alpoysius “Spanksie” Randall) Albert Dekker (Shad McClosky), Walter Abel (Commander Roberts), Mikhail Rasumny (Ivan Probenzky), Rod Cameron (Captain Pete Lewis), Philip Van Zandt (Cpl Gus Goebbels)

Films about military defeats are more a British thing than an American one. But in 1942, America needed a film to encourage men to march that long road to victory. And what could stir up emotions more than by showing the heroic last stand of American forces on tiny Wake Island against Japanese invaders, holding the island for 16 long days after Pearl Harbor. The battle was fresh news and it’s remarkable how quickly it was bought to the screen, with a skilful combination of newsreel footage, location shooting (somewhere else) and Hollywood backlot filming.

Wake Island doesn’t really shake up the expected formula. But then that’s the point. Cliches like this make for marvellous propaganda, and that’s what Wake Island really is. A grand recruitment video (its final shot is columns of American marines marching to avenge the fallen), that’s also about setting out the absolute moral certainty of the mission. To do that, it carefully fits all its characters into certain standard trope, sets up some interpersonal conflict all to show them coming together with unity of purpose.

We get Brian Donlevy as a stiff-necked, by-the-book officer, never seen dead without his swagger stick. Will he step up to the plate (after commander Walter Abel is killed in the first air raid) to inspire his men? You bet he will. Will Albert Dekker’s civilian contractor, obsessed with the bottom line and regularly clashing with the Army grunts, cast aside his walk-to-rule feelings when the first bombs fall? You bet he will, forming a fire-forged friendship with Donlevy where previously both characters were next-door to enemies.

The entire film celebrates this coming-together of patriots when danger comes, and how quickly they will fall into line to defend each other and the American dream. Robert Preston and William Bendix (recipient of a rather generous Supporting Actor nomination) are goof-off soldiers who love to moan and mock. Bendix is counting down the days to his decommissioning – inevitably his ‘last day’ is December 7th – and can’t wait to get home to his squeeze. But, of course, he will insist on joining back up (even before he’s told he doesn’t have a choice) and he and Preston will take a samurai last stand in a fox hole against waves of Japanese invaders.

Bolstering the sense of patriotic pride are several personal sob stories. Donlevy leaves a loving family behind in Hawaii as he heads to his new posting – we can tell he’s destined to never see them again. Flying ace Macdonald Carey has also left his new wife behind at Pearl Harbor: the tragic result of that decision is communicated to him in a well-shot quiet moment of literal light and shade in an airplane repair hanger. Bendix even has a beloved pet dog, that goes missing in the first raid only to be found in a later raid with a litter of puppies.

Just the right level of sentiment is found all over the place, while our heroes carry on with a stoic dedication to duty. A naval pilot flat out refuses to leave the island with vital intelligence documents until Donlevy point-blank orders him to. Soldiers carry out suicidally risky missions to try and buy their comrades a few more days. John Farrow’s punchy film brilliantly stages a series of air raids which are punishing on the base, buildings and planes exploding and bodies thrown and mangled in the explosive wake. Corpses are often found after the dust clears lying in a tragic heap.

And of course, every propaganda film like this needs an enemy. The Japanese are largely a mass of deadly but beatable soldiers, whose main strength is their limitless numbers. The only Japanese character we hear speak is a visiting dignitary a few days before Pearl Harbor, very much lying for his country. Later the military waves are plucky but no match for American grit: 24 Japanese planes are routed by a handful of American aces. When they land on the island, they are a swarm it’s impossible to overcome. They also have a relentless violence: defeated and wounded soldiers are mercilessly shot and machine-gunned, the Japanese portrayed as having no sense of any rules to this war.

It’s slightly uncomfortable today to see this whole race pigeon-holed in as a mass of rules-free killers and liars with little sense of morality. But then that’s what America then needed to hear. And Wake Island delivers the message loud and clear, using all the narrative tools in its arsenal to do it. It’s sentiment and telegraphed tragedies are well done enough that they become actual strengths, under John Farrow’s assured hand. The recreation of war is very well done, and the final last stand is as moving as it should be as, one by one, our characters are overcome by impossible odds. Is Wake Island a masterpiece? No, not really. But as a piece of war-time propaganda, it’s outstanding.

For Whom the Bell Tolls (1943)

For Whom the Bell Tolls (1943)

Lusciously shot epic, that feels more like an adventure romance film than the political work the novel was

Director: Sam Wood

Cast: Gary Cooper (Robert Jordan), Ingrid Bergman (Maria), Katina Paxinou (Pilar), Akim Tamiroff (Agustin), Arturo de Cordova (Agustin), Vladimir Sokoloff (Anselmo), Mikhail Rasumny (Rafael), Fortunio Bonanova (Fernando), Eric Feldary (Andres), Joseph Calleia (El Sordo)

“No man is an island entire of itself” is the opening of John Donne’s Meditation XVII in Devotions Upon Emergent Occasions. That’s where the phrase “never seek to know for whom the bell tolls” comes from, and it lies at the heart of Hemingway’s Spanish Civil War novel, where he and hundreds of other like-minded individuals came together to (unsuccessfully) fight Fascism with self-sacrifice for the common good a calling card. After the novel became a hit, it’s not a surprise Hollywood came calling, moulding Hemingway into an expensively mounted blockbuster.

There was no question who would play the lead, stoic American Spanish lecturer and explosives expert Robert Jordan. After all, Gary Cooper was basically Hemingway’s model when he created the character. Ingrid Bergman beat off a string of competitors to play Maria, victim of Fascist assault, now living with partisans in the Spanish hills. Jordan joins these partisans, to blow a critical bridge. But the journey not only throws up romance for Robert and Maria but also troubles with guerilla leader Agustin (Akim Tamiroff), worried the mission will imperil what’s left of his people, and his wife Pilar (Katrina Paxinou) convinced the mission must be carried out.

Sam Wood, described as a near Fascist by Groucho Marx, seems an unlikely directorial choice for a film celebrating a group of Communist guerillas. But the Second World War makes for strange bedfellows. And, in any case, For Whom the Bell Tolls is less interested in politics than Hemingway. In fact, it practically bends over backwards to remove as many references about the political stakes as it can, re-crafting the book into much more of a men-on-a-mission romp, a tragedy-tinged Guns of the Navarone.

It’s a big-budget crowd pleaser, with a handsome, exotic setting beautifully shot by Ray Rennahan, who managed to make the Sierra Nevada mountains pass as the hills of Catalonia. Mix that with the tragic romance between Cooper and Bergman, in a series of beautifully-lit lingering shots, his reserved decency contrasted with her vulnerability and nerves. Interestingly, despite being hand-picked for the role, this is one of Cooper’s dullest performances, the neutered script removing many of the character’s doubts and fears. It’s only at the end, that Cooper is given any amount of real emotional depth to play with (even if it is via a rather forced voiceover), but otherwise Wood’s film crafts Cooper into the epitome of Fedora-wearing masculine toughness and stoic strength.

Ingrid Bergman fairs a little better as the Spanish lady who wins his heart. Unlike the rest of the cast playing Spaniards, Bergman isn’t caked in layers of brown make-up (something that looks particularly awful in Rennahan’s stylish filters), but the script plays up her character’s melodramatic elements. Bergman does her best to lend dramatic weight to this, but Wood’s film keeps pushing her towards tearful outbursts of fear at the possible loss of Jordan. For Whom the Bell Tolls makes a valiant effort at exploring Maria’s tragic background but shies away from the sexuality of the novel (it did after all coin the phrase “the earth moved”). It’s ironic Bergman was desperate to land this role, but now is best remembered for her other (Morocco-based) 1943 role.

What becomes clear the longer you watch For Whom the Bell Tolls is, that for all the handsome visuals and rich scoring of Victor Young, Wood can’t find the sort of poetic, narrative depth the source material demands. Put frankly, the literary and political force of the novel feels lost to him. It’s hard not to compare this to the sort of thematic depth Lean found in the far-less-complex story of Bridge on the River Kwai. It’s telling that what Wood delivers makes Hemingway feel more like a high-brow Alistair MacLean novel. This doesn’t mean For Whom the Bell Tolls isn’t frequently enjoyable: but it does feel Wood mistakes length and sweep for complexity and depth.

The film’s complete shelving of politics plays into this. There are half-hearted attempts to understand where the guerillas are coming from, but its telling that when it comes to atrocities, more screen-time is given to the past excesses of the communists – hurling decent representatives of the old regime off cliffs to their death – rather than the ruthlessness of the fascist oppressors (even though Jordan starts the film shooting a wounded comrade rather than let him fall into the hands of the Francoists). But it’s very possible to watch For Whom the Bell Tolls and not be completely sure when exactly it is set, or what the issues are everyone is fighting about. Can that be what Hemingway had in mind when it came to the screen?

Instead, guerilla drama boils down to questions of guts and character. Akim Tamiroff (Oscar-nominated, like Cooper) gives a fine performance of ambiguous bluster as a guerilla leader who may be concerned about the lives of his men, or may just have completely lost his nerve. Tamiroff is magnificently larger-than-life, with a streak of low-cunning mixed with cowardice. Katrina Paxinou won an Oscar as his wife, the fiercely determined Pilar who deals out romantic device with the same hard-boiled grit that she plans military actions. The guerilla leadership sways between these two throughout, with just enough tension between where they will land.

But For Whom the Bell Tolls remains, at heart, a men-on-a-mission film – something that feels quite reductive considering the passion of where it comes from. Everyone seems to still believe they are actually making a literary statement. The strained sense of self-importance behind the film can make it wearing, and its telling it is at its most engaging and emotionally fulfilling when emersed in action, be that a desperate stand by a group of guerillas in the mountains or the final assault on the bridge, with the heavy cost that brings to the group.

There is another world where For Whom the Bell Tolls could have united its epic scale, military action, doomed romance, passionate humanism and boys-own adventure into something that really coherent and deep, the sort of intellectual epic David Lean would win truckloads of Oscars for 15 years later. But it feels instead torn between echoing the melodramatic sweep of Gone with the Wind with the bravo-filled heroism of Sergeant York. It can’t really square that circle, making it, like the Spanish Civil War, a doomed noble effort. An inadvertent political point, more impactful than any in the film.